The Decision Framework That Will Help You Stop Overthinking

The Hat, Haircut, or Tattoo Decision Framework: Why Most Decisions Aren’t As Permanent As They Feel

Have you ever found yourself completely stuck on a decision that, when you really look at it, probably didn’t deserve that much mental real estate? You replay conversations, analyze every possible outcome, and search for the one choice that comes with a guarantee that everything will work out perfectly.

The funny thing is, most of us aren’t actually afraid of making decisions. We’re afraid of what a wrong decision might mean about us. A choice becomes a reflection of our intelligence, our worth, or our ability to trust ourselves, and suddenly a simple experiment feels like a permanent life sentence.

This is why a decision framework can be so powerful. It gives your brain a different way to categorize choices instead of treating every decision like it carries the same level of risk.

One of my favourite frameworks is called the Hat, Haircut, or Tattoo Decision Framework. I first heard about this concept while listening to a conversation about James Clear, author of Atomic Habits, on The Diary of a CEO podcast, and it immediately stuck with me.

The brilliance of this framework is its simplicity. It reminds us that not every decision deserves the same amount of fear, analysis, and emotional energy.

The Hidden Problem: We Treat Too Many Decisions Like Tattoos

One of the biggest reasons people get stuck is because they accidentally turn temporary decisions into permanent identities. They don’t just think, “What if this choice doesn’t work?” They think, “What if this proves I’m not capable?”

That’s a very different question.

Our nervous systems are designed to protect us from uncertainty. The brain loves patterns, predictability, and knowing what happens next, which means unfamiliar choices can sometimes feel much more dangerous than they actually are.

The problem is that growth almost always requires uncertainty. You cannot collect new information from a decision you never make.

Thinking has value. Preparation matters. But eventually, action becomes the thing that creates clarity.

Hat Decisions: The Choices That Are Meant to Be Experiments

Most decisions in life are hat decisions.

A hat decision is something you try on. If it fits, you keep it. If it doesn’t, you simply take it off and choose something different.

There is no dramatic identity crisis required. There is no need to declare yourself a failure because a particular hat didn’t look quite right.

These are the decisions where the cost of staying stuck is often higher than the cost of trying. Changing your morning routine, experimenting with a new workout, testing a different marketing strategy, or trying a new creative idea are all examples of hat decisions.

The goal isn’t to get it right immediately. The goal is to gather information.

This is where the idea of failing fast, failing often, and failing forward becomes useful. Failure is not the point. Feedback is the point.

Every action gives you data. Every experiment teaches you something about yourself, your preferences, and what works.

The fastest way to know whether something is right for you is often to stop imagining the answer and start experiencing it.

Haircut Decisions: The Risks That Feel Bigger Than They Are

Then we have haircut decisions.

These are the choices that feel uncomfortable because there is more emotional investment involved. Nobody wants a bad haircut, and if you’ve ever had one, you know that moment of looking in the mirror and thinking, “Well, this is interesting.”

But here’s the thing about haircuts.

They grow back.

Haircut decisions might include changing careers, moving somewhere new, ending a relationship that no longer fits, or saying yes to an opportunity before you feel completely ready.

These choices can feel scary because they require you to step away from certainty. They ask you to trust that you will be able to handle the outcome, even if the outcome isn’t exactly what you hoped for.

But discomfort does not automatically mean danger.

Sometimes discomfort is simply the feeling of expanding beyond who you’ve been.

I often find myself admiring people who take these kinds of swings. Not because every choice works out perfectly, but because they were willing to find out.

There is something powerful about a person who chooses curiosity over fear.

Tattoo Decisions: The Choices That Leave a Mark

Finally, there are tattoo decisions.

These are the choices that carry more weight. They might involve marriage, major financial commitments, starting a business, or other decisions that can significantly shape your life.

James Clear describes these as the decisions that are difficult or impossible to reverse. While I understand the concept, this is also where my perspective differs slightly.

Because when we really look at life, very few things are truly permanent.

Tattoos can be removed. Relationships can end. Businesses can close. People rebuild after experiences they once believed they would never recover from.

What often leaves the deepest mark is not only what happened.

It is the meaning we attach to what happened.

This is where neuroscience becomes fascinating. The brain does not simply record experiences like a camera capturing footage. It interprets events, creates meaning, and builds stories about what those experiences say about us.

The event matters.

But the story we create around the event matters too.

The Mistakes You Thought Would Break You

When I look back at decisions in my own life that didn’t unfold the way I expected, I can see something I couldn’t always see in the moment.

Many of the choices I once questioned became turning points.

The relationship endings. The unexpected changes. The moments where I wondered if I had made a huge mistake.

At the time, they felt like evidence that something had gone wrong.

Later, I realized they were creating space for something new.

This doesn’t mean we need to pretend painful experiences are easy. Loss is still loss. Disappointment is still disappointment.

But we don’t have to let one difficult chapter become the entire story.

Sometimes the thing we believe ruined everything becomes the doorway to something we never could have imagined.

Why Overthinking Keeps You Stuck

I don’t think most people struggle because they are incapable of making decisions.

I think many people struggle because they are trying to eliminate uncertainty before they move.

They want proof before taking the leap. They want confidence before beginning. They want to know the ending before they are willing to start the story.

But confidence rarely works that way.

Confidence is built through evidence. It comes from showing yourself that you can make choices, adjust when needed, and handle whatever happens next.

Action creates information.

Information creates trust.

Trust creates confidence.

Waiting until you feel completely ready is often just another way of staying exactly where you are.

The Question That Can Change How You Make Decisions

The next time you find yourself overthinking a choice, ask yourself one simple question:

Is this really a tattoo decision?

Or have I accidentally turned a hat into one?

This question has changed the way I approach decisions because it helps separate actual risk from imagined risk.

Some decisions need patience and deep consideration.

Others simply need you to try them on.

The goal is not to become reckless. The goal is to stop making every choice carry the emotional weight of a permanent life decision.

Your Next Decision Doesn’t Need to Be Perfect

Life is not built through perfect decisions.

It is built through thousands of choices that teach us, shape us, and help us become who we are meant to become.

Some choices will fit beautifully. Some will need adjusting. Some will leave a mark.

But every decision gives you something valuable: more information, more self-trust, and more wisdom.

So the next time you’re standing at a crossroads, ask yourself:

Is this a hat?

A haircut?

Or a tattoo?

Then choose from there.

I’d love to hear from you. What decision are you facing right now? Have you been treating a hat like a tattoo?

Share your thoughts below.

If this conversation resonated with you, listen to The Dive Heart First Podcast, subscribe to the show, share this episode with someone who tends to overthink, and join the Community & Conversation over on YouTube.

If you’re interested in following the unfolding of the unknown with me, join the Monthly Musing Newsletter. It’s becoming a place for stories, reflections, and real-time insights as life continues to unfold.

Say hi on Instagram @diveheartfirst.

Connect, share, and dive deeper.

Get new episodes, updates, and all the good stuff.